Photo by Amy Kagan
Capitol Theater at Clearwater, Florida: For anyone who’s followed the labyrinthine soap opera that is Crosby Stills Nash and Young, the song “Cowboy Movie” – from David Crosby’s If I Could Only Remember My Name – has particular resonance.
It’s a thinly disguised parable about the quartet’s early squabbles, told as a loping Old West narrative. Eli (Stills) and the Duke (Nash) are battling over an “Indian girl” called Raven (that’s Rita Coolidge) as the outlaw gang’s other members, Fat Albert (Crosby) and Young Billy (Young) watch from the sidelines. This, of course, really happened, back in 1970. It’s what broke CSNY apart – the first time.
Today, with David Crosby and Neil Young on the outs over a public dig the former took at the latter’s new girlfriend Darryl Hannah, it seems that some things never really change. Yes, it’s déjà vu all over again. How refreshing, then, to see Crosby take the bull by the proverbial horns by putting “Cowboy Movie” front and center during his summer solo acoustic tour. (OK, it’s his encore, but we’re trying to make a point here.)
At 73, Crosby looks better than he has in decades. Of course, the walrus moustache and the lion’s mane are snow-white now, and he’s still a tad paunchier than he ought to be, but at the June 12 show in Clearwater, Florida, old Croz crowed and crooned like the Croz of old. Well, almost.
Some of the high notes were missing on “Carry Me” and “Déjà vu,” but otherwise David Crosby’s voice has retained its high-tenor warmth, and has mellowed (in a good way) considerably. Happily, he still does those jazzy, wordless vocal runs, and impeccably.
The dark horse in what remains of Crosby Stills and Nash (aka the mothership), he doesn’t do a lot of contemplative solos in their big-theater shows. And that’s too bad, because he is the trio’s most idiosyncratic songwriter, the biggest musical risk-taker, and – especially in this here 21st Century – the best vocalist. Contemporary CSN shows are touring museum pieces, all flash and familiarity. And whether or not they can still reach those golden harmonies together, well, that’s a discussion for a different day.
Alone onstage for his first-ever solo excursion ‘round the country, David Crosby was comfortable, he was chatty, and he was only too happy to play lesser-known songs, tunes from his recent Croz album (gotta promote that product!) and even a few newly written pieces. From his days in the Byrds came “Everybody’s Been Burned.” He cheerily introduced “Triad” by saying: “I gotta clear something up; this song wasn’t responsible for getting me kicked out of the Byrds.” Roger McGuinn and Chris Hillman drove to his house that day in ’68 and said, “Crosby, you’re out of the band. You’re an asshole.”
Because he writes and plays with alternative guitar tunings, Crosby used a different instrument for virtually every song. (A tech walked them out to him.) He performed “What Are Their Names” a cappella. The set list included chestnuts like “Guinnevere” and “The Lee Shore” – although Crosby adamantly refused to take requests, much to the chagrin of the drunken lout who kept calling for “Almost Cut My Hair.”
Instead, we got “In My Dreams,” “Naked in the Rain,” “Thousand Roads,” “Rusty and Blue” and Joni Mitchell’s “For Free” (one of the few played in standard guitar tuning). The audience (except for that one guy) was rapt and receptive for the entire concert, which Crosby gratefully acknowledged.
Crosby-Nash shows are fun and (mostly) musically satisfying. (Those two still harmonize like nobody’s business.) Throw barking, growling Stephen Stills (and a band) into the mix, however, and things get loud and sloppy. That’s where the money is, though, so they have to do it. And they do it a lot.
But David Crosby, alone and acoustic, now that was something special.
- John Lennon and the American Left: ‘Some Time in New York City’ (1972) - August 5, 2015
- Carly Simon – Another Passenger (1976): Forgotten Series - August 1, 2015
- For Crowded House’s 1991 Masterpiece ‘Woodface,’ It Was Death by Chocolate - July 19, 2015
With Stills things get ‘loud and sloppy’ – charming! I suspect the writer is not a fan of ‘electric music’ – heck their renditions of the power ballads is a triumph, not sloppy at all!
Saw Crosby the other night now seeing Stills and a band in Richmond, VA next month. Can’t wait.
My sentiments exactly. We saw the June 17 show in Charlottesville at the lovely and acoustically perfect Paramount Theater. I’ve seen some iteration of CSNY about 6 or 7 times. This may have been the best. So emotional. So beautiful. It’s incredible how his voice has survived in tact all these years.
“This video has been removed by the user.”
Graham Nash will be here in Eugene, Oregon on July 17. I’ll be there.
Totally agree. I try to catch CSN whenever they play New York City (I consider it a gift every time) but I love to see a Crosby/Nash show best of all, unfortunately t happens so rarely. (Stills really doesn’t sing well these days, perhaps his voice went with his hearing.) I’ll be seeing Crosby play Town Hall this week in NY, looking forward to it (he always was my favorite of the bunch.)
I didn’t find Crosby ‘special’ at Clearwater. As a matter of fact, I thought he was totally inappropriate. Clearwater at 6:00 at night is not the place for the type of commentary he was providing. “Fuck” and “Asshole” way too many times, joking that he was a feminist just to get laid (not funny), and saying he wouldn’t sit through the weather we were all sitting in, combined with the slowest, dreariest opening selections made the show I was waiting for a huge disappointment. I think his ego is still “as big as the Washington Monument”. There was far better music and entertainment at the other tents. I miss the CSN (and sometimes Y) of years ago. Perhaps C’s past is just a good bye.