In interviews, I’ve seen Lyle Mays speak of how music has it’s own “language and syntax.” He wasn’t necessarily talking about music’s technicalities — harmony, melody, and the like. Instead, it was those ideas that can only be expressed through music. Now, I’ll grant you that it’s very difficult to describe this phenomenon, but maybe that’s the point.
“September Fifteenth,” Pat and Lyle’s unspeakably beautiful tribute to Bill Evans, always makes me think of Mays’ ideas of musical meta-language. Does knowing the composition’s intent somehow get in the way of a listener’s understanding? As some say analysis of a poem might do? I don’t think so.
Early on, Metheny is playing the acoustic guitar inside of Mays’ pastoral synth washes. I’ve always been struck by the changeover, when Pat rides on four chords, introducing Lyle’s short melody on the Oberheim. After that, Lyle switches to piano and the pair are locked in for a time. The interplay is both delicate and intimate…exactly what Bill Evans’ career was built on. But when Pat steps back for Lyle’s solo passage? Incredible.
I’ve seen them play this live a few times and it’s always stunning.
Up next: It’s For You
Latest posts by Mark Saleski (see all)
- Todd Rundgren, “Love in Action” from Back to the Bars (1978) - December 20, 2015
- Rolling Stones’ harrowing ‘Gimme Shelter’ is still revealing new depths - December 5, 2015
- Pat Metheny – 80/81 (1980): Track by track through a classic - December 2, 2015